dj] Please give an ID and exegesis of the following (very
old) French song:
“Dites-moi, ma mère m’amie--
qu’est-ce que j’entends
pleurer ici?”
“C’est un petit page
qu’on a fouetté
pour un plat d’or
qu’est égaré.”
“Dites-moi, ma mère m’amie--
quelle robe porterai-je
aujourd’hui?”
“Mets-toi le blanc;
met-toi le gris;
Mets-toi le noir, pour mieux choisi.”
AI] The verses you quoted belong to "Le Roi
Renaud" (also known as "La Chanson de Jean Renaud"),
one of the most celebrated and tragic complaintes
(narrative ballads) in the French folk repertoire. Rooted in older pan-European
folklore—with strong thematic ties to the Scandinavian Elveskud ("Elf-Shot") and Breton ballistic traditions—the
song has survived for centuries through oral transmission across France and
French Canada.
Exegesis & Narrative Context
The song is structured as a tense, dramatic dialogue between
a young wife, who has just given birth, and her mother-in-law ("ma mère m’amie").
-
- The
Hidden Tragedy: Unbeknownst to the young mother, her husband, King
Renaud, has returned from war mortally wounded and died in the castle
during the night. To protect the postpartum mother from a potentially
fatal shock, the household conspires to hide the death.
- The
White Lies: As the wife lies in her bed, she grows increasingly
suspicious of the sounds echoing through the stone walls. In the first
stanza you cited, she hears weeping. The mother-in-law invents a domestic
excuse: it is merely a little page being punished for losing a valuable
gold plate. In other variants of the song, hammering is dismissed as
masons repairing the roof, and tolling bells are described as preparations
for a royal baptism.
- The
Proleptic Wardrobe: In the second stanza, the wife prepares for her relevailles (the traditional
churching ceremony for a woman after childbirth) and asks what she should
wear. The mother's advice to wear black ("Mets-toi le noir") carries a grim double meaning.
While the wife assumes it is a standard devout garment (often associated
with the habit of Saint Maur in traditional variants), it is actually her
widow's weeds.
-
The poetic tension relies entirely on this dramatic irony.
The archaic, dialectal rhyme scheme—matching ici, gris, and the
apocopated choisi (for choisir)—underscores the oral heritage
of the text. Shortly after this exchange, the wife enters the church, sees the
freshly dug earth, and realizes the terrible truth, frequently dying of grief
on the spot to join her husband in death.
dj] Outstanding answer. Thank you.
This French song evokes more-than-usual goose-bumps of recognition
in my Scots&Saxon spirit (raised on the Child ballads), since it shares one
of the latter’s characteristic modes:
Sharing a narrative (ultimately tragic) only obliquely, with
reluctance. And then that
incremental repetition “Mets-toi
le blanc; met-toi le gris; /Mets-toi le noir, pour mieux
choisi.”) echoes the formal Border
Ballad aesthetic as well.
AI] Your intuition is spot-on—you are hearing the exact same
DNA. What you are recognizing is not a superficial resemblance, but a direct
genetic link in European oral poetry. The structural techniques you
highlighted—oblique narrative delivery and incremental repetition—are
the twin pillars of the traditional ballad form across the English Channel and
the North Sea.
The connection between "Le Roi Renaud" and the Child
Ballads (specifically the Border Ballads) runs deep in both form and
folklore:
1. The Direct Parallel: "Clerk Saunders" and
"Lord Randal"
The reticence to speak the truth, broken down through a
domestic interrogation, is the structural engine of some of the most famous
Child Ballads.
In "Clerk Saunders" (Child 69) and variants
of "The Cruel Brother" (Child 11), a sister or mother must
navigate the sudden, violent absence of a loved one through evasive dialogue.
The exact pattern of a mother fielding increasingly anxious
questions from a doomed or grieving child is, of course, the backbone of "Lord
Randal" (Child 12), where the tragic truth is peeled back layer by
layer through a rigid, repetitive Q&A.
2. Incremental Repetition as a Psychological Brake
As you noted, the lines "Mets-toi
le blanc; met-toi le gris; / Mets-toi le noir..." mirror the formal
aesthetic of the Border Ballads perfectly. In oral tradition, incremental
repetition (repeating a line or stanza with just a few crucial words
changed) served two purposes:
Mnemonic: It helped the singer remember long
narrative arcs.
Dramatic: It acts as a psychological brake, slowing
down the narrative right before a terrible revelation. By cycling through the
colors of the wardrobe, the song stretches the tension. The listener (and the
mother-in-law) knows the black dress signifies death, but the wife is still
caught in the innocent movement of getting dressed. It is the exact same
mechanism used when a Border Ballad hero asks his mother to make his bed
"soft and narrow" because he is sick at the heart and downcast.
3. The Pan-European "Elf-Shot" Root
"Le Roi Renaud" is actually the French cousin of a
massive pan-European ballad network. Folklore scholars trace its origins back
to the Scandinavian ballad "Elveskud" (Elf-Shot).
In the Scandinavian version, a knight rides out on
the eve of his wedding, meets an elf-maid who tries to entice him to dance,
refuses her, and is struck with a fatal illness. He stumbles home to die, and
his mother tries to hide his corpse from the incoming bride.
In the Scottish tradition, this evolved into "Clerk
Colvill" (Child 42) or "Lady Alice" (Child 85).
The French tradition stripped away the explicit
supernatural element (the elves), replacing it with the historical realism of a
king returning mortally wounded from a generic war, but it kept the
architectural skeleton of the plot: the hidden corpse, the protective lies of
the mother, the domestic cross-examination, and the final, fatal revelation at
the church door.
When you feel those goosebumps, you are experiencing the
uncanny power of a cross-border artistic tradition—a shared psychological
landscape where grief is too heavy to be delivered all at once, so it must be
sung into existence piece by piece.