Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts

Saturday, November 7, 2026

Occultist Iconography of Groupuscules

 

My customary petit-déjeuner consists of  a French-pressed mug of java, plus a side-dish of the French press.   Nowadays, whenever an unfamiliar expression obtrudes, relief is just a key-click away.  I polled Monsieur Bot-à-langues;  transcript follows.

 

 

dj] Browsing the breakfast papers, I came across an unfamiliar expression in Le Monde, “gants à coques”.

 

AI]

Lors d'un meeting du Rassemblement national (RN) à l'Arena d'Orléans, le 25 octobre 2026, des militants et membres d'un groupe d'ordre parallèle ont violemment expulsé des membres de l'UEJF (Union des étudiants juifs de France) ainsi que des journalistes

Le « Groupe action mobile 75 » et « Kaiser » : L'enquête met en lumière les méthodes d'un groupe de choc mené par un individu surnommé « Kaiser », dont l'accoutrement diffère du service d'ordre classique du parti (le DPS) --

des gants à coques (gants munis de renforts rigides sur le dos de la main et les phalanges),

 

dj] The article continues:

“Ils arborent aussi à l’épaule ou sur leur sacoche  un gros écusson rond  sur lequel figure un aigle aux immenses ailes jaunes devant une tour Eiffel et portant l’inscription « Groupe action mobile 75 ».

What is the symbolism of this yellow-winged eagle?

 

AI] The insignia described by Le Monde heavily mimics the visual codes of official French police intervention units—specifically elements found on tactical gear within the Prefecture of Police in Paris.

 

The Police Aesthetic (Mimicry and Camouflage)

The Yellow-Winged Eagle: In French tactical imagery, the eagle (often with spread or stylized wings) is a frequent symbol for airborne, mobile, or rapid-response security units. For example, similar eagle iconography is used by various regional Compagnies d'intervention (CI) or specialized support units.

 

2. Private Security & Far-Right Coding

According to the investigation, the "Groupe action mobile 75" is an informal choc-group led by a Parisian merchant nicknamed "Kaiser". In his private business, he designs, collects, and sells tactical gear, pouches, and custom patches to actual police officers and gendarmes.

 

dj]  And why yellow?  Surely it is not a mere allusion to the amateurish “gilets jaunes”.

I am thinking in particular of the *black* spread-winged Reichsadler, which the rechte-Szene Liedmacherin Freya sports prominently as a tatoo on her neck.

 

AI] The article reveals a practical, operational reason for the color yellow: the group used yellow-headed lapel pins (une épingle à tête jaune) on their chests to recognize one another. In a crowded, chaotic stadium where multiple security forces (the official DPS, local arena security, and the police) are present, a bright, unnatural color like high-visibility yellow allows an informal "group de choc" to instantly differentiate allies from targets without wearing an official uniform

 

In France, yellow and blue are the primary colors associated with police road safety, motorized units, and specific intervention markings (such as the high-visibility yellow bands on tactical gear and vehicles).

 

Your mention of the black Reichsadler highlights a deliberate tactical shift within modern nationalist security groups:

 

Traditional neo-Nazi elements historically relied on overt, stark black-and-white or red-and-black imperial iconography (like the symbols popular in the subculture surrounding figures like Freya).

The New School ("Militant-Chic"): Groups operating close to mainstream political parties like the RN actively avoid those precise historical markers to protect the party's image. Instead, they pivot to "tactical chic" or private security aesthetic. A bright yellow-winged eagle in front of the Eiffel Tower allows them to deploy a powerful, aggressive raptor symbol while completely bypassing anti-hate laws and party directives against overt neo-Nazi symbols.

 

It is less an amateurish nod to the Gilets Jaunes and more a calculated blend of functional combat identification and tactical mimicry—allowing a group led by an individual calling himself "Kaiser" to project militant authority

 

dj]  > A bright yellow-winged eagle in front of the Eiffel Tower allows them to deploy a powerful, aggressive raptor symbol while completely bypassing anti-hate laws

 

Yes, they are treading a fine line -- a kind of political funambulism in which their Gleichgesinnten beyond the Rhine are more experienced.

Yet my semiotic Spidey-sense is still tingling.  The name “Kaiser” appears in the very headline of that article.   Now,  the figure of Wilhelm II  butters no parsnips in France, whatever your politics.  But that odd stand-out title “Kaiser” does rather conjure up, in pentimento, another title, again a Germanic troche, ending again in a growling -r, for an individual known to his later military detractors as the “Gröfaz”.   Are the RN followers expected to perceive that echo, or is it simply an inside joke?

 

AI]  In French political discourse, using an overt reference to the Gröfaz (Größter Feldherr aller Zeiten—the mocking acronym for Adolf Hitler) or traditional Nazi terminology  is a legal and public-relations death-sentence. It triggers immediate prosecution under French anti-hate laws and violates the Rassemblement National’s strict "dédiabolisation" (de-demonization) directives.

 

By utilizing "Kaiser"—a reference to the German Imperial monarchy rather than the Third Reich—the individual adopts a Germanic, authoritarian archetype while maintaining a layer of plausible deniability. If confronted, the imagery can be defended as a nod to historical Prussian discipline, imperial aesthetics, or simply a tough-sounding tactical alias, rather than overt national socialism.

 

For those fully immersed in the ultra-nationalist and neo-fascist subcultures, these linguistic and visual proximity games are entirely legible. Within these circles, the use of a German trochaic title ending in that heavy "-er" sound does not exist in a vacuum. It functions as an esoteric dog whistle:

 

To the General Public: It looks like standard, aggressive "militant-chic" branding common in private security.

 

To the In-Group: It acts as a wink to a broader pan-European, Germanic-inspired martial aesthetic. It bridges the gap between French nationalism and the more rigid, aggressive stylistic codes of the German radical scene, signaling a shared ideological lineage without crossing the line into illegal symbology.

 

dj] The earlier heraldic Adler, from the HRE to the Deutscher Bund, was two-headed.   Later, from Weimar through the Third Reich down to the BRD, one head sufficed (as it does for Freya).   Have any groupuscules or milieux resurrected the Doppeladler as an esoteric symbol?

 

AI] Yes, the resurrection of the Doppeladler (double-headed eagle) as an esoteric and political symbol is a highly distinct phenomenon within specific radical milieux. While mainstream post-war German neonazism heavily favored the stylized, single-headed Reichsadler of the Third Reich (with an Iron Cross, a Celtic cross, or a sun wheel substituted for the illegal swastika), the Doppeladler has been reactivated by groupuscules operating on the ideological fringes of Traditionalism, Austro-fascism, and Pan-Eurasian esotericism.

 

1. The Austro-Fascist Revival (Ständestaat Nostalgia)

In German-speaking central Europe, the most direct historical precedent for an explicitly anti-democratic, modern deployment of the Doppeladler lies in Austro-fascism (the Ständestaat regime of Engelbert Dollfuss and Kurt Schuschnigg, 1934–1938).

 

Seeking to purge the single-headed eagle of the democratic first Austrian Republic, the Dollfuss regime revived the imperial Habsburg Doppeladler. To them, the two heads symbolized Austria’s historic "Catholic imperial mission" and its defense of the West against both Bolshevism and secularism.

 

Today, minor monarchist, traditionalist-Catholic, and radical right-wing identitarian factions in Austria quietly revere this specific Austro-fascist Doppeladler. It serves as a visual rejection of modern parliamentary liberalism, looking back toward a clerical-authoritarian corporate state rather than the explicitly pagan-materialist Third Reich.

 

2. Radical Traditionalism and the "Eurasian" Esoteric Axis

Within the esoteric, intellectual far-right—deeply influenced by thinkers like Julius Evola and René Guénon—the Doppeladler has undergone a profound metaphysical rehabilitation.

The Two Heads as Spiritual and Temporal Power: In this milieu, the two heads do not represent a nation-state; they represent the Ghibelline ideal—the perfect union of supreme spiritual authority and absolute temporal power under a single, sacred sovereign ruler.

The Eurasian Milieu: This esoteric symbolism is most aggressively deployed by the international Nouvelle Droite (New Right) and Neo-Eurasianist circles (such as those surrounding Alexander Dugin in Russia). For these groups, the Doppeladler (drawing also on its Byzantine and Romanov lineages) represents a geopolitico-mystical bridge between Europe and Asia. It is used as a standard against what they view as the "degenerate, single-headed, western transatlantic consensus."

 

3. The "Do.Ra." Movement (Italy)

A concrete, contemporary example of a militant European groupuscule actively using the Doppeladler is the Italian neo-fascist organization Comunità Militante dei Dodici Raggi (Do.Ra.), based in Varese

While deeply rooted in National Socialist aesthetics (frequently employing the Black Sun), variations of Do.Ra.'s official iconography and tactical logos prominently incorporate a heavily geometric double-headed eagle.

For a modern Italian neo-Nazi group, using a German-inspired or Byzantine-inspired Doppeladler serves a dual purpose. It functions as a powerful, aggressive symbol of imperial hierarchy, while remaining legally ambiguous enough to complicate swift prosecution under Italy’s Scelba Law (which bans the direct reconstitution of the National Fascist Party)

 

dj]  Hmm.  Wheels within (sun-wheels);  not to mention the Hakenkreuz-adjacent triskelion.

 

> Dodici Raggi

 

What’s that?

 

AI] Your semiotic radar is spot-on: "Dodici Raggi" translates directly from Italian as "Twelve Rays."

 

The Black Sun consists of twelve radial Sig runes (the lightning-bolt style runes used by the SS) fanning out from a central hub, forming a wheel.

The Nazi Origin: The most famous physical manifestation of this symbol is a green mosaic inlaid into the floor of the Obergruppenführersaal (General's Hall) at Wewelsburg Castle, which Heinrich Himmler remodeled to serve as the ideological and spiritual headquarters of the SS.

The "Twelve" Connection: The number twelve carries immense weight in SS mysticism. Himmler envisioned Wewelsburg as a "Camelot" for his elite, centered around a round table for twelve top SS group leaders (the Reichsleiter).

 

By naming themselves the "Militant Community of the Twelve Rays," the Do.Ra. group accomplishes exactly what we discussed regarding "Kaiser" and the yellow-winged eagle: they encode an illegal symbol directly into their group's name.

 

Under Italian law (specifically the Scelba and Mancino laws), displaying a swastika or an overt SS rune can lead to immediate arrest for apologizing for fascism. However, naming your association "Twelve Rays" sounds abstract—almost spiritual or solar—to the uninitiated public or a standard police officer.

 

Your mention of "wheels within wheels" captures the exact structural design of these symbols. The Black Sun, much like the Triskelion (the three-legged wheel used prominently by the South African AWB and various white supremacist groups), relies on rotational symmetry to create a dynamic, spinning wheel.

 

dj]  > runic

 

AI] When the Third Reich collapsed, its primary graphic assets—the Hakenkreuz and the double-sig rune of the SS—were banned across most of Europe. To survive, the post-war rechte-Szene turned to the broader Futhark (runic alphabet), specifically utilizing runes that had been co-opted by the Ahnenerbe (the Nazi ancestral heritage bureau) and the SS.

 

1. The Odal Rune (ᛟ) — The Stand-In for Blood and Soil

Originally representing "heritage," "estate," or "inherited land" (Odal), this rune was modified by the SS with two small "feet" or serifs at the bottom and used as the insignia for the 7th SS Volunteer Mountain Division Prinz Eugen.

 

Following the ban on the swastika, the Odal rune became the premier global surrogate for "Blood and Soil" (Blut und Boden) ideology. It was used by the banned German neo-Nazi youth group Wiking-Jugend and, more recently, was adopted by the National Socialist Movement (NSM) in the United States to replace the swastika on their banners.

Because it is an actual character from an ancient alphabet, a militant wearing an Odal rune patch can disingenuously claim they are simply celebrating Norse paganism, Celtic heritage, or Viking history, leaving prosecutors legally hamstrung.

 

2. The Tyr Rune (ᛏ) — The Arrow of Martial Sacrifice

The Tiwaz or Tyr rune looks like an upward-pointing arrow and historically symbolized the Norse god of war and justice. Under the Third Reich, it became the badge of the SS officer training schools (Reichsführerschulen) and was worn on the sleeves of SA and SS veterans.

 

Today, the Tyr rune is the central emblem of the Nordic Resistance Movement (NRM), a militant, pan-Nordic National Socialist organization operating in Sweden, Finland, and Norway.

 

The Wolfsangel (The Wolf's Hook) — The Tactical Threshold

 

While not strictly a letter of the elder Futhark, the Wolfsangel is a runic-style heraldic symbol representing a medieval wolf trap. It was used by early Nazi organizations and famously adorned the panzers of the 2nd SS Panzer Division Das Reich.

 

The Wolfsangel has seen a massive resurgence in Eastern European militant aesthetics over the last decade. It was notably used in a stylized, inverted form by the original iteration of the Ukrainian Azov Battalion.

Because the Wolfsangel has deep roots in traditional municipal German heraldry (appearing on the coats of arms of various towns to this day), its political deployment carries a built-in historical shield.

 

dj] > Because it is an actual character from an ancient alphabet, a militant wearing an Odal rune patch can disingenuously claim they are simply celebrating Norse paganism, Celtic heritage, or Viking history, leaving prosecutors legally hamstrung.

 

Yes, it’s difficult to anathematize a single letter of the alphabet.  But , for the potency of even a single letter, compare the 1969 political-thriller film directed by Costa-Gavras:  “Z”  (the image was featured very prominently in its publicity).  It likewise worked very well for Zorro -- the TV series of my tender years  thrillingly blazoned that symbol (“This bold renegade / carves a “Z”  with his blade’/ -- a “Z” that stands for *Zorro *!”)

 

AI] What makes your observation so sharp is that this graphemic warfare is not confined to the 1960s or 1950s television. We saw this exact phenomenon play out globally in 2022, when the Russian military adopted the letter "Z" (originally a mere tactical vehicle marking for the Western military district) and transformed it into a ubiquitous, state-sponsored symbol of the war in Ukraine. Almost overnight, a letter that doesn't even exist in the Cyrillic alphabet became an aggressive totem worn on shirts, displayed on billboards, and used to signal absolute loyalty to the state.

 

dj] Ah… This rabbit-hole has become overly deep and twisty.  Time to return to the clear sunlight of an autumn day.

A la prochaine,

Dr J


 [end of transcript]

For more on the whirly triskelion, and further flags appropriated by European groupuscules, in a manner opaque to anyone but insiders and iconographers, check this out:


https://worldofdrjustice.blogspot.com/2014/09/flagge-verbot.html


Wednesday, May 6, 2020

When is the Task Force not the Task Force?


In May 2020, with the coronavirus still raging, President Trump said he was ready to “turn the page on all that”, and announced that the covid Task Force that had been led (apparently at the bottom of a mine-shaft somewhere) by the Vice-President (whose name  escapes me at present, and shall continue to do so in future) was being “disbanded”.  (In the French press reports of the anouncement, this verb was rendered démantelé -- ‘dismantled’, which sounds even more alarming.)  That offhand ad-lib caused consternation, so he “re-spoke” himself (verb ©WoDJ 2020, All Rights Reserved).  He now states that the Task Force will continue "indefinitely" -- albeit with substitute members and different mission. -- The young reporter who was obliged to recount all this on NPR, noticed a certain “philosophical question” here, whether this would be the “same” task force or not.

The philosophical problem alluded to  is that of Continuity of Identity, with many ramifications ancient and modern.  We have touched on some examples in these posts:


Meanwhile, herewith a handful of miscellaneous quotations, illustrating the variety of concerns:

Simon Blackburn (Think (1999), p. 127) quotes the joke about Irish axe that had been in the family for generations, the head having been replaced three times and the helve six; and asks whether Theseus’ ship, rebuilt plank by plank over the course of the voyage until no original molecule remained, was the “same” ship; and if so, what if someone had saved all the discarded planks and built a replica, this with all the original molecules, was that the “same” ship as well.

.

A modern example, with wry phrasing:

The truck had been a Renault back in the twenties, but had become, over time, a collection of replacement parts  cannibalized from every sort of machine.
-- Alan Furst, The Spies of Warsaw (2008), p. 146

And with a quite different topology:

The Romans who traversed the plains of Hungary  supposed that they passed several navigable rivers .. but there is reason to suspect that the winding stream of the Theiss  … might present itself in different places  under different names.
-- Edward Gibbon, The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire (1776-1788)

Of current concern among Anglo-Saxon analytic philosophers:

Since these world-lines define the individuals we quantify over when we use modal logic (more accurately, when we ‘quantify into’ modal contexts), we do not have well-defined individuals at our disposal in any realistically quantified modal logic.
-- Jaakko Hintikka, “Quine on Who’s Who”, in Hahn & Schilpp, eds., The Philosophy of W. V. Quine (1986), p. 210

The Quinean position (on the "block universe" picture):

The space-time view helps one appreciate that there is no reason why my first and fifth decades should not, like my head and foot, count as parts of the same man, however dissimilar.  There need be no unchanging kernel  to constitute me the same man  in both decades,  any more than there need be  some peculiarly Quinian textural quality, common to the protoplasm of my head and feet;  though both are possible.
-- W.V.O. Quine, Word and Object (1960), p. 171


Tuesday, March 3, 2020

Bonnet Blanc vs. Blanc Bonnet


Bonnet Blanc versus Blanc Bonnet

(Or, synonyms, at daggers drawn)

I once wrote an MA thesis called Linguistic Life on the Left, a historical-semantic survey of the Berkeley linguiscape during my time there as a graduate student.  It sifted out correlations between a sect’s self-expression,  and its (sometimes partly subconscious) ideology.  A favorite schematic example  was this  one:
Given that: Groups A, B, and C are all part of what popular or pre-theoretical conception would consider “the Left” (albeit that seeming Big Tent  turns out to be a granfalloon).
And that:  Group A denounces Group C as ‘pigs’, while Group B denounces group C as ‘swine’.
From this we can conclude: virtually nothing about Group C; but that Group A and Group B are bitter enemies, barely sharing any verbiferous ether that could even attempt to pass coherent messages between them.

For: Group A derived the epithet from the rants of the American Black Panthere; Group B derived theirs from the European Marxist polemical tradition (nineteenth century et seq.)  A vast host of incompatible cultural assumptions go with each.  In keeping with the expressive ethos of the two groups, we can call the vituperative practices of A as "badmouthing"; of B  as "the ironical-polemical style".  Both manners, when well done, can afford aesthetic pleasures.

~

And now we have the following situation, in the context of the controversy over illegal immigration.
Entity A described the immigrant-source regions as “shit-holes”.
Entity B described them rather as a ‘snake-pit’.

Once again, these two entities, along with their fanbases, are not on speaking, let alone reasoning terms.

Entity A is POTUS;  Entity B is a Circuit Court of California.  [My source for that was NPR’s All Things Considered; for some reason, a string-search in Google news is not turning up anything relevant.  Thus evanescent are the bubbles that burble from the media.]  From similar observations, A and B draw opposite conclusions.  A: Who would want to bring in people from such areas?  B: Who would be so unconscionable as to send people back to such areas?

There is another linguistic/political parallel between that case and the one described in the previous section.  In either case, one term of the “synonymic antithesis” is more populist in tone (pigs; shithole), the other more literary and traditional (swine; snake-pit).

Saturday, February 22, 2020

Right-wing support for left-wing candidates


Reports that Putin’s Russia has been attempting to load the electoral dice in favor of Bernie Sanders,  likely startled adherents of monolinear manicheanism, but that sort of thing is a time-tested gambit.  There is a notable parallel from the Presidential campaign of 1972.  A historian writes:

What all the 1972 dirty tricks that had become known as “Watergate” were intended to accomplish:  sabotaging all the other Democratic candidates  in order to leave Geroge McGovern, the field’s weakest link, as the last man standing.
-- Rick Perlstein, The Invisible Bridge (2014), p. 170.

Additionally, Nixonian operatives went about “drumming up fake enthusiasm for the black female candidate Shirley Chisholm" (id., p. 171)

The strategy worked.   McGovern received the nomination, then a shellacking in the general election, losing in 49 states.


~


Hunter Thompson, describing the Democratic convention in his entertaining Fear and Loathing on the Campaign Trail ’72,  via interviews with the pols and pros of the delegate floor, describes considerably more byzantine maneuvers -- feints, pawn sacrifices, “shaving”, sitting-out a round, taking a dive, lowballing your vote-totals till the propitious time -- telos and kairos being the watchwords.




Sunday, January 6, 2019

Fun Furlough Reading


Many of you may know some poor unfortunate Federal worker who has been reduced to a piteous and meaningless existence by the furlough.   What (you ask yourself) can You do to help??

Wonder no longer!  Here is a list of perfect Furlough Gifts -- thrilling reading to keep your loved-one functionary from drifting into senility and despair:



.


.




All of them available -- with free excerpts -- here:
http://www.linguasacrapublishing.com/justice.html



.

Sunday, January 21, 2018

The Logic of Yea and Nay


The Senate has just shot itself in the foot;  with shrapnel ricocheting onto masses of bystanders.  The move might enter the annals as “Shumer’s Self-mate”.

In the face of such legislative absurdity, the Administration floated the idea of reducing the minimum to pass a Continuing Resolution  from 60%  to a bare majority.    Worth discussing;  but there is a more general logical point behind the whole debate, which seems to have garnered little or no notice in print.

The point is, across the board, the status quo is the default.   As the cock crows, the Senate (to take that as an example, but the point applies to any established body) begins its busy day with various activities.   Everyone shows up for work with teeth brushed and appropriately dressed (men as men, women as women);  there is some sort of opening ceremony (in my primary school, these were Flag Salute and Lord’s Prayer);  a roll-call is taken;  citizens are admitted to the visitors’ balcony; interviews are given to the press;  and so forth.   It would be legitimate to question any one of those activities:  require unisex attire; ban the prayer or the flag salute (some of this has already happened in this venue or that); skip the time-wasting roll-call; exclude spectators (for security, or whatever).  To do that, you introduce a bill, which for passage requires a majority of some weaker or stronger preponderance (say, 60%), depending on the nature of the proposed bill.   What is not required is that,  in order to continue to wear normal clothes, or salute the flag, or what have you, the body must, every morning as the cock crows, pass a brand-new bill (with the required 60%) to continue the status quo.   The burden is on those who would change or disrupt the status quo.

Now, allowing the government to continue putt-putting along, for better or worse, is simply the default, and should be so considered.  It’s the government’s job.   So it is truly not logical that Congress should be obliged to seek a super-majority, simply to keep the government open for business, fulfilling the promises made.    Anyone who would disrupt that scenario, at so fundamental a level, should be obliged to propose doing so, in a measure  -- say, the Government Shutdown Circular Firing-Squad bill -- that itself would require the supermajority.   Instead, the quite radical maneuvre of wrecking the government   is relieved of what should logically be its burden, as though that were the default.


[Update 22 Jan 2018]  The Washington Post today has a good article on the logical/structural parameters of such situations.


https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2018/01/22/why-other-countries-dont-have-government-shutdowns-2/?hpid=hp_hp-top-table-main_wv-shutdown-1105am%3Ahomepage%2Fstory&utm_term=.a67ef5b32d8a
 
 
 
 
 

Sunday, January 7, 2018

The Double Truth


It is clear by now that the old Averroist doctrine of the “double truth” (veritas duplex)  must be revived:  this time, not along scientific-vs-theological lines, but political.  Radio talk-shows have long recognized the incommunicability of one set of truths, to partisans of the other, by offering separate Republican vs. Democrat call-in lines.

So, let us consider that simplest possible area of human belief and inquiry:  arithmetic, the discipline that offers up such hoary verities as “2 + 2 = 4”.  
In modern mathematics, the study of such numbers (called integers)  has exfoliated quite a bit, and indeed has bifurcated into named subdisciplines.   Thus we have, on the one hand, analytic number-theory,  which deals with such things as the Riemann hypothesis and the Goldbach conjecture, using techniques from complex analysis, and on the other, algebraic number-theory, involving extensions of the integers such as algebraic number-fields.   Both subfields have developed to such an extent, that specialists in the one will be scarcely able to understand, let alone prove, theorems in the other;  thus reproducing, unintentionally, a simulacrum of the current partisan Dialogue of the Deaf.


And now we have two new entrants to the disciplinary matrix:   Democratic number-theory and Republican number-theory.

Democratic number-theory is characterized (up to isomorphism) by its claim that all numbers are equal.   The denial of that doctrine is termed ‘fascism’.

Republican number-theory, by contrast, generalizes the ancient concept of a perfect number (equal to its aliquot sum) to that of the awesome numbers, which are greater than the sum of everybody else.  The leftovers are called the  pathetic numbers (also termed ‘losers’).  This theory focuses exclusively on the former subset (although the membership in this set  can vary capriciously  from day to day).

So far, neither body of theory has produced interesting theorems.



[Update 8 Jan 2018]   No sooner had I posted that would-be satirical thought-dream, than I happened upon this,  by the philosopher Stewart Shapiro:

Hartry Field takes mathematical language at face value.  Since he holds that mathematical objects do not exist, mathematical propositions have objective but vacuous truth-values.  For example, he maintains that ‘all natural numbers are prime’ is true, since there are no natural numbers.
-- Thinking about Mathematics (2000), p. 226

So once again, reality beggars satire.  (Apparently this Field fellow is some sort of an academic, rather than an inmate or homeless-person.)

Note, a propos, that the Fieldian assertion “all natural numbers are prime”  is actually an axiom of Democratic number-theory.   (“Everybody gets a trophy.  Everyone is special.”)



[Historical footnote]    If satire is the production of humor by clever exaggeration of a real situation, then here again the satire lacks its bite:  for such ideologically infected strains of the hard sciences  are already exemplified in history -- not merely in the musings of philosophical fantasists, but under dictators with the power of life or death.   Thus Hitlerian notions of Aryan science vs. Jewish science, or the various scientific orthodoxies under Stalin.    Under those two regimes, mathematics, fortunately, was relatively spared distortions of actual content (so long as the formulaic obeissances to ideology were packed into the preface),  though  in human terms  there were profound and pernicious effects on who was allowed to be mathematical practitioners.   The neo-Stalinoid zealots of “anti-racist mathematics” go further, prescribing severe limits to content and presentation as well.

Tuesday, June 13, 2017

Does the President lie through his teeth?


(Again, not this one; that one.)

January 1962 -- the silent escalation.

“Mr President, are American troops now in combat in Vietnam?”
“No.”
That was not true.  Vietnamese pilots sat next to the Americans so than any U.S. casualties could be announced as accidents on training missions.
-- Richard Reeves, President Kennedy:  Profile of Power (1993), p. 280

A thin entering wedge.  The rest is history.

Monday, June 12, 2017

Does POTUS despise those he courted during the campaign?


No no, not the current guy -- the one campaigning in 1960:

Happy farmers were not a principal Kennedy goal.  … After his agricultural speech … at the South Dakota State Fair, he had remarked to Richard Goodwin:
“Well, that’s over.  Fuck the farmers after November.”
-- Richard Reeves, President Kennedy:  Profile of Power (1993), p. 277

Friday, June 9, 2017

Do we even effectively have a President?


Again no no -- no reference to current controversies.  The time is July 1961; the speaker is Dean Acheson, President Truman’s Secretary of State, and a member of JFK’s executive committee during the Berlin crisis:

Acheson reacted to mention of Kennedy’s name by saying: “Gentlemen, you might as well face it.  This nation is without leadership."
-- Richard Reeves, President Kennedy:  Profile of Power (1993), p.  196

(This precedent is also relevant to current gossip about “sniping at the President from within his own Administration".)


And, I.F. Stone, writing 1 Sept 1958,  during Eisenhower’s second term:

It is tragic that  just when another irrepressible crisis looms ahead  there should be such a nobody in the White House.

Saturday, March 4, 2017

The I’s have it (or, ISIS it is)


A couple of years back, when the media was confused about the labels ISIL versus ISIS, I posted a politico-linguistic explanation:


Summary:

(1)  The expert bodies that had been following the group from the start (State Department, IC) used ISIL, where the “L” stands for “Levant”, which is the closest equivalent to the term in the Arabic name for the group,  al-Shâm, which includes Syria, Lebanon, Jordan and Palestine.
(2)  Since that is what he’d been hearing from his briefers, that is what President Obama said.
(3)  Possibly by confusion with the name of the goddess Isis, along with the unfamiliarity of the term Levant among the laity, the popular media took to using ISIS, despite the fact that this term singles out only Syria.   (As a sideshow to this, certain conspiracy-minded lo-info voters tried to read some nefarious significance into President Obama’s continued use of the term ISIL, that he and his discussion-mates had been using all along.)

But now we have a new POTUS -- one who, for most (or actually, still all) of his life, has paid more attention to the pop media, than to academia or the State Department.  And he says “ISIS” -- just like they do on TV.


Accordingly -- and gracefully -- government entities have bowed and followed suit:  where previously their briefing-papers used ISIL, now they use ISIS.
The IC thus arrives, by a circuitous route, at exactly the position advocated by The New Yorker a year ago:  to speak “ISIS” with the vulgar, but to maintain an academical-casuistical mental reservation, to the effect that the final “S” stands not for “Syria”, but for… al-Shâm.
 And thus does language evolve.

“Wes Brot ich ess’,  des Lied ich sing’.”

Given recognition at last



[Footnote:  An alternate explanation, that you’ll hear around town,
is that the use of ISIL was nixed because people couldn’t figure out how to pronounce it.  Some IC miscreants were even pronouncing the word to rhyme with pizzle.  (Look it up.)  And this, despite our wise guidance here:


Wa-Llahu-a`lamu.]


~

Actually -- there's a bright side to the switchover to “ISIS”:
(1)  That “Levant” business was always a stretch on ISIL’s part.  They never did get a real foothold outside Syria.
(2)  As for any association with the goddess Isis, that’s great:  any depiction of that goddess, ISIL would destroy on principle, so quasi-“naming them” after her  can only annoy them.   (For similar reasons, some people say Da’esh, since ISIL doesn’t like it.)


A propos of nothing at all;  added merely to annoy ISIS

. 

Sunday, January 15, 2017

"Great Question"


Two flatulent practices relating to the posing of questions  have characterized political discourse in recent years, to the disbenefit of the polity.

(1)  Particularly associated with Donald Rumsfeld, though the maneuver antedates him, is posing ‘questions’ to oneself and immediately answering them.  Thus, let P and Q be propositions:  instead of saying simply

P.  Not-Q

the rhetorician draws it out into a monologue masquerading as a dialogue:

Is P true?  Sure it is!  Is Q true?   Absolutely not!

The advantages to the speaker are:

(a)  He gets to choose the ‘questions’, irrespective of whether anyone is interested in them or whether anyone would phrase the question in that manner.   As a result, they are invariably softball ‘questions’.
(b)  He gets to dwell in a bubble of his own voice.  Reporters, voters, maiden aunts, all fade into a kind of Meinongian subsistence;  and the Dialectic collapses to a trivial instantiation in the palaver of a single man.

Disadvantages to the audience include:

(c)  There is usually a substantive concern whether some proposition P be true, or what to do about it, or the like.   Yet by this slight-of-tongue, the bloviator poses instead some verbally related but substantively etiolated variant P-prime, and addresses that instead, thereby providing no real information or analysis, but leaving the impression that he has addressed P.
(d)  You have to listen to twice as much verbiage as for a straightforward “P” -- ten pounds of rhetoric in a five-pound bag.  And in time it gets freaking annoying.


(2)   In politically pre-sanitized settings like “town-halls” and related social Spectacles, an array of voters, carefully selected to represent each of the pressure groups to be pandered to, is permitted to pose a simple-minded, vaguely worded question, thus pushing a given button on the candidate’s library of prerecorded on-message speechlets.   But in a new development, the politician moves to snuggle-up to said Potemkin voter, with an enthusastic

   “Great question !!”

before launching in to her canned response.

The practice, repeated ad nauseam  (cf. SNL’s parody of Hillary Clinton’s use of this and similar maneuvers, in their satire of the Presidential ‘debates’), is distressing  even apart from its smarminess.    For the sort of low-info voter who most needs to be buttered-up and flattered, is least in position to actually pose a “great question”, or even a probing or pointed one.    Nor will, say, a scientist giving carefully-prepared, expert testimony on a complex subject  be patronized from the Congressional panel with a “Great question!”   The domains of “Great question!” and great questions, are virtually mutually exclusive.


Note:  The catchphrase “Great question!” is characteristically contemporary;  but the maneuvre is of longer date.   Speaking to a group,

Nixon would react to the most elementary question  as if he was hearing it for the first time.  He would ponder a bit, congratulate the questioner on his originality,  then give the answer he had given  hundreds of times before,  complete with some figures and a quotation,  as the citizen listened  in utter awe.
-- Stephen Ambrose, Nixon: the Triumph of a Politician 1962-1972 (1989), p. 139

~

And now, by an unhallowed congressus of these two tricks -- by Beelzebub out of Medusa -- comes the Great Rhetorical Question.  One came up this morning on NPR.


A Republican senator was touting Trump’s intention to
(i)  Increase spending (e.g. on infrastructure and defense)
and
(ii) Decrease taxes,
while
(iii) Holding down the deficit.

Now, this nation has been down that road many times before, both in speechifying and in practice;  so apart from the apparent logical incompatibility among those three desiderata, there is a track-record here, for anyone who cares to examine it.   That, however, is beyond the capacity of most pop journalists practicing today, as well as the attention-span of the average voter.    The substitute for critical inquiry, is a mere statement of undifferentiated unwillingness to be convinced -- the lazy-man’s lo-cal substitute for genuine skepticism (anatomized here).   In this case, the reporter’s Clarence-Darrow move was simply to ask, again, how (i)-(iii) might cohere.   But the politician was ready for it:


“Yes -- How can we address the problem of doing the things that need to be done, while holding the line on the deficit, without addressing the question of Entitlements? -- Great question!”

That may or may not be a Great Question, but the reporter had not posed it;  the rhetorician was congratulating himself.   And in so doing, bait-and-switched the subject from the incompatibility of (i)-(iii) to the problem of those pesky Entitlements.  A perfectly legitimate subject of debate, but here snuck-in via a side door.


~

The considerations above  recall to mind  what, for Europeans, must be the original Potemkin-“question” scam:  to wit, the Socratic dialogue.


The scenario has been solemnly sanctified,  countless times  over many years decades centuries.  The method has been dignified with the title  maieutic (etymologically relating to widwifery), whereby the savant or solon, by adroit interrogation, draws forth from the naïve listener (like a tapeworm from the bowel) innate knowledge  such that all might marvel that he hath.

As a build-up, this is terrific, only… You actually read the texts, and what you see is Socrates holding forth, more or less commendably, and harvesting the plaudits of uncomprehending minions or yes-men.



Thus, a demonstration of the Urysohn Metrization Theorem, via the Socratic method.

Socrates:  Let us, therefore, consider any topological space whatsoever, so that it have a countable basis.  You agree?

Minion: Sho’ nuff, boss!


Socrates: And may we not further stipulate, that said space be regular?  -- Surely that is not too much to ask!

Minion: True dat, Socrates!!

Socrates:  Whence it follows that, our space being regular, for any point thereof, we may define a continuous function  positive at that point, but vanishing outside of a neighborhood of that point. -- You agree?

Minion: Word up dawg, Socrates !!!!

Socrates: Whereupon we may plainly see, that by defining an infinite series of functions from said space, to …

(Socrates drones on;  the minion dozes, but his snores are taken as assent.)

Socrates: Whereupon we may plainly see, that our original space may be smoothly embedded into the countably-infinite Cartesian-product of the cube, which we earlier (you do recall this, don’t you, minion?) proved to be metrizable.  This metric is inherited by our embedded space in the subspace topology, thus proving the theorem.

Minion:  U da man, Socrates !!!

Socrates (beaming upon the evidently innate insight of his pupil):  Great answer !!!

Note:   We have it on good authority from the memoirs of Oxford dons, that any tutor who attempts to apply the Socratic “method” to draw wisdom out of the maws of wool-gathering undergraduates, comes up empty.