Two surprising statistical statements appeared in this
morning’s press. No idea how much
truth there is in them, but worth following up.
*
[Update, 20 April 2015] Well, no point belaboring. People mostly have their minds made up, or don’t want to
hear about all this; and when
minds do change, they will likely change in a rush, all at once, as the world
goes toppling over some tipping-point.
Emotion, not reason, will rule.
But purely as a point of logical interest -- we take note of
what is not being said -- what lies
even deeper than taboo, since people are unaware even of repressing it. Consider this map:
Notice anything?
Well of course, the floundering boats are nearly always
closer to Libya than to Europe;
but nobody ever suggests that Libya has any responsibility for saving
their co-religionists just
offshort (even though, additionally, Libya is responsible for launching these
assault-boats against European shores). Yet that is not what I mean -- everyone knows that
Libya is a failed state and always has been. No, I mean -- look at the map. That's Tunisia, just to the left.
Tunisia is a reasonably well-functioning country, and indeed
a tourist resort for Europeans.
Yet no-one suggests -- it never occurs to anyone to suggest it -- that
Tunisia might have any responsibility, equal to or greater than that of
Europeans, in rescuing their fellow-Muslims.
[Update 22 April 2015] Mais -- rappel à l’ordre. Ce n’est pas dans nos rayons, que de critiquer la politique comme telle. Si la culture d’Europe désire se
donner la mort, en s’africanisant -- c’est leur affaire. Nous, en tant qu’observateur de
la psychologie linguistique, on n’a que faire en la matière. Ainsi, ne commentons que la côté “rhétorique
publique”.
Donc: Il y a un
décalage entre le discours médiatique, et le vox populi.
Celui-là ne faisait guère mention de l’expérience
australienne, qui a réussi, à la fois, à juguler l’afflux tiers-mondiale, et à
réduite la mortalité en mer des impétrants à zéro. En revanche, les commentateurs grand-public la signalent à
haute voix.
Finally the European media had to pay attention, after
Aussie PM Abbott referred to his country’s success. The response of European politicians and talking-heads
(those gleichgeschaltet to The Narrative), was flustered, and resembled the
magician’s distractive patter.
A logical parable:
Elbownia is considering sending a vehicle to the Moon. The idea is shouted down: It would never work -- the ship would
have to escape our planet’s gravity, which is impossible; moreover the asteroids whizzing around
just above the Earth’s atmosphere
would quickly bash the ship to bits; plus the Moon has no atmosphere, so the ship would explode
were it ever to arrive.
Then someone says:
But, umm, … the United States already tried it; and it worked.
(Elbownian politicians clap hands over ears and chant LA LA
LA LA ….)
[Update 23 April 2015]
In this whole Mediterranean melodrama, there is one thing that every faction, of whatever shade of opinion,
unanimously agrees upon. And
that is, that the “smugglers” --
the “Human Traffickers” -- are the bad guys. They serve the convenient role of “Neo-Nazis” for Hollywood
studios that want to make an international thriller without offending any
group: Just make the bad guys
Neo-Nazis. (Or, in pinch -- just
German will do. The Germans
themselves will never object:
whipped curs.) The Italian
Prime Minister came up with a metaphor that has been enthusiastically embraced
by everyone: the “Traffickers” are
the contemporary equivalent of … Slave Traders! (All in unison:
Booooo, slave traders!
Kumbaya.)
That comparison is, however, nonsense. The négriers, after all, kidnapped their victims; whereas the would-be migrants
themselves come forward and solicit the traffickers’ services. As for the traffickers, you
can’t really even call them smugglers, since their SOP is the opposite of
clandestine: Send out a rafiot; then call the Italian sea-taxi service for free-of-charge
rescue and pizza (200 mushroom,
400 anchovies, 12 sausage -- no, cancel that last order, those were the
Christians, they just got thrown overboard). A closer historical parallel to the traffickers would would
be … the Underground Railroad. (Albeit one that charges for its
services.) Or, from another
standpoint: A sort of mirror-image
of Club Med.
Francois Hollande, for his part (less imaginative, that man)
calls the traffickers “terrorists”.
-- Umm… No. How are they
terrorists? They just want to make
a buck. -- True, some proportion
of their cruise passengers are likely terrorists -- ISIL has promised as much
-- but that no more makes the cruise operators terrorists, than the airlines
were, when they carried the 9/11 hijackers, or the shoe bomber, or the
underwear bomber, etc.
[Update 24 April 2015]
Another cockeyed but widely-repeated argument from the Ostrich Lobby (as
we might dub them) runs thus: By
defending your borders against the traffickers, you would actually be … helping the traffickers, see, because,
see, you’d be raising the price of
passage. (High-fives among the
bisounours for having thought up this one.)
Now, that is true in the same sense that, by making heroin
illegal, scarce, and hard to come by, we force up its price: If the authorities were simply to hand
out heroin free to every schoolchild beginning with kindergarten, the dealers
would be out of business. An
analog of this latter policy is, in fact, the program of those who say that
borders are inherently a bad thing.
To which we respond, with the poet: “Good fences make good neighbors.”
[Update 3 May 2015]
The flood continues, unabated -- nay encouraged, by stepped-up European ramassage -- 4000 and counting, in a
single day.
Different publications spin the story differently. Thus, Le Figaro (centre-right) tops its
article with a brooding busful of all black adult males:
while CBC (Care Bears Canada), reporting the same incidents, offers a jolly portrait of a
manageable handful of only women and children, smiling, flashing peace-signs, as though enjoying a picnic at sea:
Oddly, though, the readers are not fooled by this
prepackaging. Read the
comments. Taceo.