So the ague-fever dreams of freedom have spread to
Istanbul. And once again,
the spark was no economic development, but a spiritual imponderable, just as in Tunisia: The authorities had
a sort of Stalinoid bureaucratic vision for transmogrifying a park -- “They
paved Paradise, put up a parking-lot.”
It was like that in Berkeley, too, when I lived there: People’s Park, nothing but a
semi-vacant and highly unsightly lot off Telegraph Avenue, overrun by dogs and
vagrants, but a symbol to the die-hards.
De Toqueville nailed it when he identified the Revolution
from Rising Expectations, rather than objectively increasing tyranny. The ground-shaking
developments in the Muslim world
have no evident economic motivators -- none that were not equally in
place ten, twenty, fifty years
ago. Nor is it really the
spread of ideas (these are surprisingly few; emotions, rather), nor even Exemplary Action: if anything, you would think that the
dreadful results of the insurrection in Syria would give potential insurrectionists pause. Nor do Iraq, Egypt, Libya or Tunisia offer a hopeful model.
-- Likewise, you would have thought that Erdogan, contemplating the
example of Assad (and Mubarak, and Gaddhafi) might have thought twice about playing
the tyrant card…
And so the Zeitgeist rolls, groans in its sleep. And its brain-born
feverdreams people the planet.
~
Philological footnote:
The three names above look similar because each is in origin
a verbal noun (masdar) of a form-II Arabic verb.
In each case, the final vowel is long, and hence receives the
stress: tahh-REER, tagh-YEER,
tak-SEEM. (That “gh” is a gargling
sound, similar to the Parisian “r”.)
Tahrîr means ‘liberation’; Taghyîr
means ‘change’ (click here for an explanation of why that square in
San`aa is so named); and Taksim … well, taksim doesn’t
necessarily mean anything, it’s just the Turkish spelling of a word borrowed
from Arabic,
ميدان
تقسيم
I have no idea why the square was named that. Literally, taqsîm means ‘division’, quite at variance with the usual Mideast
fetish for Tawhîd (‘unity,
unification’; also ‘monotheism’).
~
For a more generous collection of morphosemantic remarks
about Arabic, check out this:
~
The real issue is the attraction of
violence on the personal level, in Turkey, Syria, Lebanon, etc.. Unstable
societies with large components of young men with little to lose plus religious
divisions and no protection for minority religious groups. But then most wars
have always been holy wars.
My response:
That is a giant issue in societies generally,
to be sure; but, it by no means
explains the movements symbolized by the three Squares here.
The current, potentially
revolutionary situation in Turkey
was unleashed by a government plan to cut down some trees in a park, and
the protestors are to a great extent women. Nor does religion particularly figure in this one.
The very oddity and symbology of
these "Square" protests are what make them intriguing.
Indeed, specifically in the Turkish case, the symbolism of
that Square as the site for a militant ongoing sit-in, is especially
piquant. In the expert words of
Wikipedia:
Taksim Square (Turkish: Taksim
Meydanı), situated in the European part of Istanbul, Turkey, is a major tourist
and leisure district famed for its restaurants, shops, and hotels. It is
considered the heart of modern Istanbul
(And no, don’t imagine for a moment that the infallible
Wikipedia, greatest of all the gods, has nodded here by so much as a jot or a
tittle -- specifically, the jot or dot over the final vowel of Meydanı. That is indeed
orthographically a dotless “i”, its pronunciation comparable to that of the
similar Russian vowel in non-palatal contexts. Indeed, these
vowels are not only phonetically but phonologically similar, since neither
contrasts phonemically with the
tenser variant, being rather conditioned by the palatal/nonpalatal
environment.)
[Update 29 June 2013]
This morning’s Washington Post offers an intriguing survey of ‘Taksim’-like
developments around the globe, emphasizing their volatility, unpredictability,
and elusive etiology. The
trigger can be something as offbeat as this:
In the Bosnian capital of Sarajevo, thousands of furious residents
across ethnic lines united on the streets this month, at one point blockading
lawmakers inside parliament for 14 hours to protest government ineptitude in
clearing a massive backlog of unregistered newborns. Public anger erupted
after a Facebook posting — about a 3-month-old baby whose trip to Germany for a
lifesaving transplant had been delayed by the backlog — went viral.
Sarajevo, recall, is celebrated in history as the locale
where a seemingly minor insident -- the 1914 assassination of a ducal royalty
whose name otherwise would not even have come down to us -- proved the spark
for a world-wide powder-keg.
[Update 26 juillet 2013] The latest from Tunisia (miserere nobis, domine):
http://www.lefigaro.fr/international/2013/07/25/01003-20130725ARTFIG00425-assassinat-de-brahmi-les-tunisiens-dans-la-rue-pour-exprimer-leur-colere.php?m_i=yXBy57EcWebF6MMv7ybMT6Jvg_pN_HEjADD0NFNrgb%2B4w4CyM
[Update 26 juillet 2013] The latest from Tunisia (miserere nobis, domine):
http://www.lefigaro.fr/international/2013/07/25/01003-20130725ARTFIG00425-assassinat-de-brahmi-les-tunisiens-dans-la-rue-pour-exprimer-leur-colere.php?m_i=yXBy57EcWebF6MMv7ybMT6Jvg_pN_HEjADD0NFNrgb%2B4w4CyM
No comments:
Post a Comment