We earlier spoke of the prison experiences of the stellar
mathematicians André Weil and Neil Koblitz (“Adventures
on Algebraic Geometry”). It turns out that the author Arthur Koestler
-- though not himself a mathematician -- likewise had fruitful recourse
to math while imprisoned; and, like Weil and Koblitz, was in prison for
(roughly speaking) an unjust war (in this case, that of the Nazi-backed
Franquistas against la
República
in the Spanish Civil War). As recounted
in an excellent biography:
Koestler concluded that his hours
spent by the prison window
scratching equations had
brought mystical insights into another realm of being. He was filled “with a direct certainty
that a higher order of reality existed, and that it alone invested existence
with meaning.” Koestler likened it
to “a text written in invisible ink;
though one could not read it, the knowledge that it existed was sufficient to alter the texture of
one’s existence.”
-- Michael Scammel, Koestler
(2009), p. 150
From this metaphor, Koestler drew the title of his
psycho-political memoir, The Invisible Writing.
[Footnote: One might include Galois -- another
anti-tyrant -- in this company. Though not imprisoned, he carried out his
last great work under effective sentence of death.]
[Post-footnote: We are each of us, actually, under
sentence of death.]
[Update 23 November 2013] From the memoir of a front-rank mathematician, and refugee
from Soviet oppression:
While in prison, Weil wrote a
letter to his sister Simone Weil, a famous philosopher and humanist. This letter is a remarkable
document; in it, he tries to explain in fairly elementary terms (accessible
even to a philosopher -- just kidding!) the “big picture” of mathematics as he saw it. Doing so, he set a great example to follow for all
mathematicians. I sometimes joke
that perhaps we should jail some of the leading mathematicians to force them to express their ideas in
accessible terms, the way Weil did.
-- Edward Frenkel, Love &
Math (2013), p. 96
~
~ ~
Other historical examples:
Poncelet in prison, reviving
projective geometry.
Not everyone is so tough:
Brouwer would spend many a university holiday in the army.
The most lasting effect of his military training was that it ruined
his health and his nerves.
-- Dennis Hesseling, Gnomes in the Fog: The
Reception of Brower’s Intuitionism in the 1920s (2003), p. 28
.
No comments:
Post a Comment